Gripping, realistic account of middle-class, maternal anxiety in Tokyo, inspired by real-life events that shocked Japan
In November 1999, a two-year old child went missing in Bunkyo ward, Tokyo. Three days later, a 35-year-old housewife, an acquaintance of the mother of the child, confessed to strangling the child and burying the body in woods in rural Shizuoka prefecture. Referred to as the 'Bunkyo Ward Infant Girl Murder Case' or the 'Otowa Entrance Exam Murder Case', the case caused a huge, media frenzy at the time. More notable than the shocking details of the actual incident was the way in which the narrative within the media evolved and eventually u-turned, as Japanese society struggled to comprehend how a middle-class mother could commit such a crime. The initial reaction of outrage against the offender, who was labelled 'oni-haha' (demon mother) by the tabloid press, gave way to a more sympathetic viewpoint, as fellow housewives expressed empathy with the feelings of frustration and isolation that can accompany child-rearing in modern Japan. There were even accusations of bullying against the mother of the victim (although these were later retracted).Whatever the truth of the circumstances, the incident and the debate surrounding it clearly made a deep impression on Japanese society, particularly on award-winning author Kakuta Mitsuyo, who uses it as a motif for Mori ni nemuru sakana, first published in Japan in 2008. The novel explores several themes brought up during the debate surrounding the Otowa case, including the intensely-competitive school entrance exam process, which starts at nursery (kindergarten) in some parts of Japan, the immense pressure on Japanese women to take complete responsibility for childrearing, and the isolation many full-time housewives feel in a society that does little support them. Although I should point out, while this novel is inspired by real-life events, it is entirely fictional.
The story begins in 1996 and runs until 2000, told from the viewpoints of five housewives living in a 'Bunkyo-chiku' or 'school zone' in Tokyo. The relationships between Chika, Hitomi and Yoko, whose sons attend the same nursery, form the central crux of the novel. At the beginning, the 'mama-tomo' (mummy-friends) seem to be united in their resolve not to become 'kyoiku-mamas' (education mums), obsessive mothers who force their children to attend cram schools and take up extra-curricular activities in order to pass entrance exams for elite, elementary schools. Chika, the most extroverted of the three, is adamant she will not force her will on her child; she refuses to scold him when he is disobedient and insists she will allow him to have a say over which school he eventually attends. Introverted Hitomi and Yoko lack the confidence and conviction that Chika exudes, but neither do they possess the stamina for the exhausting, entrance-exam process nor the financial means to send their children to expensive private schools should they succeed. Distanced from the kyoiku-mama clique, the three form their own social group, including a fourth member, Mayuko, bonding during playdates and lunches.
However, as external pressures and internal anxieties soon come to bear on the women, they are forced to rethink their outlooks, which puts a strain on their close friendships. They are interviewed by a writer researching the elementary school entrance exam phenomenon, which exposes differences between the women. Later, Chika finds herself drawn to Kaori, a neighbour of Mayuko's, who is nicknamed 'madam' because of her affluence and refined posturing. Kaori seems to be the perfect housewife, with her impeccably-stylish mansion flat, her designer clothes and her well-mannered daughter who attends a reputable private school - a lifestyle that Chika secretly covets. All the women have their secret anxieties or weaknesses, even the outwardly-confident and collected Chika and Kaori, which contribute to the tension that gradually builds up and undermines their friendships. Hitomi has a history of eating disorders; Yoko suffers a miscarriage and an unsympathetic husband; Mayuko falls into debt; Chika is secretly jealous of her flighty younger sister; Kaori's domestic life is not as blissful as it seems. As the women begin to drift apart, these anxieties, multiplied by misunderstandings, become heightened to the point where any one might be pushed over the edge. As the tension ramps up, any reader with prior knowledge of the Otawa incident will feel their sense of unease steadily increase. I also found the portrayal of Mayuko, the youngest and newest mother of the five, as an irresponsible, uncouth gyaru-mama, who speaks in street-slang and feeds her infant daughter junk food, rather derogatory. However, despite my reservations, Kakuta's realistic depiction of middle-class, maternal anxiety, told in a gripping, narrative style, kept me hooked to the last page.
