I read an interesting article on education this week. It appeared in an English-language magazine (Japan Close-Up, April 2011) published in Japan and concerned Japanese education primarily, but I think the issues it covered have wider implications too.
Japan once topped international tables for educational attainment but now languishes behind its Asian neighbours. Chinese students now achieve the highest scores in maths, science and reading tests administered by the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA). Taiwan, Singapore and South Korea also feature in the top five. Meanwhile, Japanese maths scores slipped from first place in 2000 to 10th place in 2006 and ranked ninth in the latest data from 2009.
The education authorities in Japan are blaming this drop in attainment on relaxed education policies brought in during the nineties. At the time, problems of school violence, bullying and children refusing to go to school were blamed on the academic pressures faced by Japanese children. The government is attempting to reverse this policy and is considering increasing the amount of time children spend studying maths, sciences and foreign languages. They point to the huge achievements made by their Asian neighbours, where academic competition is very stiff and children spend hours after school cramming for various entrance exams.
The issue of deteriorating educational standards is a familiar one in the UK. It's something we've been debating and worrying over for years. Looking at the PISA results, it's not just this country that is under performing. Along with the UK, the US, Germany and France also failed to make it into the top 10, despite being wealthy countries highly reputed for their technological and scientific innovations. Many believe a general lack of competitive spirit and 'dumbing-down' of the educational curriculum have led to falling standards. This argument has its merits, but the answer to this problem might not lie in simply pushing children harder. One country has proved to be an exception to the rule.
Finland has regularly featured in the top three PISA rankings. It hasn't achieved this through stiff competition for educational resources or intense academic pressure. On the contrary, the Finnish system is comprehensive, non-selective and focuses on the development rather than testing of pupils. What Finland offers its children are highly-qualified teachers free of constraint, individual support and equal access to education. These are just some of the reasons cited for its academic success.
While the achievements of the Asian tigers is significant and commendable, clearly, there is more than one way to reach success. Will they follow Japan's path and burn out too?
No comments:
Post a Comment